If you’ve been scrolling Amazon for a countertop ice maker, you’ve probably noticed the Silonn sitting near the top with over 10,000 reviews and a 4.3-star average. It’s one of the most popular budget ice makers on the platform right now, and for good reason. This silonn ice maker review breaks down whether it actually lives up to all that buzz, or if you’re better off spending your money elsewhere.
What You Get for Around $80
The Silonn countertop ice maker (the standard 26 lb/day bullet model) is a compact machine that sits on your counter and churns out ice without needing a water line. Fill the 2-liter tank, press the button, and you’ll have 9 bullet-shaped ice cubes in about 6 minutes. Over a full day, it can produce up to 26 pounds of ice.
You get two size options for the bullet ice (small and large), a self-cleaning mode, a removable ice basket with scoop, and a transparent lid so you can watch the ice form. The control panel is simple with just a few buttons and indicator lights that tell you when the basket is full or the water runs low. There’s no app and no Wi-Fi. It just makes ice.
Dimensions are compact enough to fit on most kitchen counters without taking over, and it comes in several color options including black, silver, green, and white.
Who Should Consider This Ice Maker
This machine fits a specific type of buyer. If you don’t have an ice maker built into your fridge, or if your built-in one is slow and unreliable, the Silonn fills that gap for less than the cost of a nice dinner out. It’s also popular with RV owners and people who host often. Anyone with a mini fridge in a home office or garage will get good use out of it, too.
However, if you’re after nugget ice (the soft, chewable kind from Sonic), this isn’t it. Silonn does sell a separate nugget ice model, but the standard bullet version reviewed here makes hollow, bullet-shaped cubes. They cool drinks fast, though they melt quicker than solid cubes from a traditional freezer tray.
For anyone browsing the home and garden picks on this site, it’s one of the more practical small appliances you can add to a kitchen.
The Good Stuff
The speed is genuinely impressive. Six minutes from empty tray to a batch of 9 cubes is fast enough that you can keep up with a small gathering without pre-making bags of ice. The self-cleaning cycle is a nice touch, too. One button press runs water through the system, and it takes about 10 minutes.
Noise levels are reasonable during normal operation, sitting around 35 dB at idle. That said, when the compressor kicks in during active ice production, it gets noticeably louder. Think quiet background hum, not silent. You’ll hear it in a quiet kitchen, though it won’t overpower a conversation.
Setup is essentially nonexistent. Unbox it, let it sit upright for a couple hours (standard for any compressor appliance), fill the tank, and go. There’s no plumbing or installation, and no filter to buy.
What’s Disappointing
The transparent lid looks nice but feels cheap. It’s thin plastic, and you’ll want to be careful not to drop anything on it. For a machine that otherwise feels reasonably well-built, the lid is a weak point.
Ice quality is fine for drinks but nothing special. The cubes aren’t perfectly uniform, and they won’t look crystal-clear like what you’d get from a commercial machine or even a good silicone mold. If presentation matters to you (cocktail parties, for example), these won’t impress.
Maintenance is the bigger concern for long-term use. If you’re filling the tank with tap water, mineral scaling builds up significantly faster than with filtered or distilled water. Silonn recommends cleaning every two weeks, but with hard tap water, you might need to do it more often or deal with off-tasting ice. Using distilled or filtered water makes a noticeable difference here.
Also worth noting: this silonn ice maker doesn’t store ice. There’s no freezer compartment, so the ice sits in the basket and slowly melts back into the reservoir to be recycled. If you need ice ready to grab hours later, you’ll want to transfer batches to a freezer bag.
How It Stacks Up Against the Competition
The two closest competitors worth looking at are the Frigidaire EFIC189 and the Ecozy portable ice maker.
The Frigidaire EFIC189 is the more premium option in this category. It has the same 26 lb/day capacity, but its ice basket is better designed with firmer plastic that’s easier to scoop from. Cycle time is a bit slower at around 9 minutes per batch instead of 6. Build quality is a step above the Silonn, though you’ll pay more for it. If you want the most consistent ice output and don’t mind spending extra, the Frigidaire is the safer pick.
The Ecozy portable ice maker matches the Silonn almost spec for spec: 9 cubes in 6 minutes, 26 lbs per day, noise under 35 dB, and self-cleaning. The base model is priced similarly to the Silonn. Where Ecozy pulls ahead is with its smart models that offer Wi-Fi connectivity and Alexa voice control, though those cost more. For the standard non-smart model, it’s basically a coin flip between Ecozy and Silonn.
The Silonn wins on price and availability. It’s almost always in stock, frequently on sale, and has the deepest review pool on Amazon, which makes it easier to spot potential issues before buying.
Silonn Ice Maker Review: Is It Actually Worth Buying?
Yes, with a caveat. The Silonn is the best countertop ice maker you can get for under $80, and for most people that’s all they need. It makes ice quickly and it’s dead simple to operate.
But it’s not a premium product. The lid is flimsy and the ice won’t win any beauty contests. You also need to stay on top of cleaning if you use tap water. These aren’t dealbreakers for a machine at this price point. They’re tradeoffs.
If you just want cold drinks on demand without messing with ice trays or waiting for your freezer, the Silonn does that job well. If you’re willing to spend more for better build quality and more consistent results, the Frigidaire EFIC189 is worth the upgrade. Still, for the price, the Silonn earns its spot as Amazon’s top seller in this category. This silonn ice maker review comes down to a simple question: do you need ice fast and cheap? Then buy it.
Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, Gabi’s List may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. This helps support the site and allows us to continue providing honest product recommendations.